Thursday, September 20, 2018

Investment policy Of Pakistan

Investment policy 

Investment policy relates to a country’s laws, regulations and practices that directly enable or discourage investment and that enhance the public benefit from investment. It covers, for instance, policies for transparent and non-discriminatory treatment of investors, expropriation and compensation laws and dispute settlement practices. The quality of a country’s investment policies directly influences the decisions of investors, be they small or large, domestic or foreign. Transparency, property protection and non-discrimination are core investment policy principles that underpin efforts to create a quality investment environment for all. Investors are also concerned with the way that investment policy is formulated and changed. They will avoid circumstances where policies are modified at short notice, where governments do not consult with industry on proposed changes and where laws, regulations and procedures are not clear, readily available and predictable. The Investment Policy chapter identifies through eight questions the most important issues relevant for judging the effectiveness of a country’s investment policies and practices. The issues are often directly relevant to the specific needs of foreign investors, but they apply in most instances to domestic investors as well. This section of the Toolkit offers additional detail on why these investment policy questions are important, and specific guidance on the topics to scrutinise in order to form an opinion on how well a country’s investment policies perform vis-à-vis good practices. The eight questions on Investment Policy relate to:   Laws and regulations   Effective ownership registration   Intellectual property rights   Contract enforcement and dispute resolution   Expropriation laws and review processes   Non-discriminatory treatment for national and international investors   International co-operation and periodic review   International arbitration instruments

The first Investment Policy introduced in Pakistan by Board of Investment (BOI) was given in 1997, which opened services, social, infrastructure and agriculture sectors for foreign and local investors. It was a major step forward for integration of Pakistan’s economy into international markets as prior to this policy; foreign investment was restricted to manufacturing sector only.


For an investor, the expected relative risk/return ratio is the driving force of investment decisions. Therefore, they tend to invest in countries and projects where they expect the highest returns and the lowest risks relative to alternative investment opportunities. Pakistan’s success in attracting foreign investment thus depends on its competitiveness as an investment location relative to other countries. Boosting Pakistan’s international competitiveness on a global scale will be crucial in reaching Pakistan’s growth targets in general and its FDI targets in particular. Pakistan is widely perceived as a high risks investment proposition. A pro-active campaign will be launched under this FDI Strategy to enhance Pakistan’s international image as an investment location. International investors must be persuaded that Pakistan, despite challenges, offers investment opportunities with risk/return ratios outcompeting alternative opportunities elsewhere. This calls for a strategy concentrating on identifying, developing, marketing and facilitating “Competitive Projects” in Pakistan.
 
Broadly speaking, fragile business environment due to uncertain policies and poor governance; security issues for an extended period of time; energy shortages; and low public sector investment due to severe fiscal constraints, are some of the key factors responsible for depressed investment activities. Moreover, global economic conditions in the past few years also became unfavorable: great recession following the financial crisis during the last decade, debt crisis and economic slowdown in Europe, and turmoil in emerging markets have squeezed the international liquidity available with investors.

Causes of lower investment in Pakistan 
Business environment Business conditions have remained increasingly difficult for investment in Pakistan, particularly with the political uncertainty of 1990s, terrorism in 2000s, and deterioration of general law and order in big cities, like Karachi – the hub of economic activities of the country. In terms of business regulations also, Pakistan’s performance has shown deterioration, as evident from World Bank’s index of Ease of Doing Business (EDB), which has worsened during the last ten years
EDB index is based on a number of sub-indices, in most of which Pakistan ranks poorly: construction permits (61), protecting minority investors (25) and resolving insolvency (94), starting a business (122), getting electricity (157), registering property (137), getting credit (133), paying taxes (171), trading across borders (169) and enforcing contracts (151).
The unfavorable business conditions in Pakistan have not only kept foreign investors away from the country, but also dissuaded local businesses from expanding and/or reinvesting.
Resultantly, the investment rate in Pakistan, which was around 18 percent in 2000s, declined to only 15 percent in recent years.


Policy weaknesses Although Pakistan has lately achieved a reasonable sense of stability on the political front, it has a history of frequent changes in political regimes, which had compromised the quality and consistency of economic decision making. Policies were mostly guided by adhocism, particularly in case of public sector investment, without taking care of long-term objectives and genuine national priorities.4 For example, successive governments introduced several incentives for power generation in the country, but transmission and distribution remained largely inattentive. As a result, despite large investments in power sector and use of tax payers’ money to pay for this sector’s inefficiencies, power shortages are still impacting businesses and households. Similarly, a number of incentives were given for investment in fertilizer, power and CNG sectors with a commitment of uninterrupted gas supplies. But such commitments were made without having a fair assessment of available gas resources. Such weaknesses in policy making not only impacted existing businesses but also kept away new investment

Low public investments Public sector investment, particularly in infrastructure, crowds in private investment. In case of Pakistan, the public sector has played a leading role in developing capital stock and had a very high share in total investment until 1990s. However, its share has been declining since then (Figure 4). One obvious reason is increasing fiscal constraints due to low tax-to-GDP ratio and meager external financing, which hardly allows the government to spend much on development programs. Moreoever, ailing PSEs have also been eating up public resources for last many years. Lack of resources is not the only problem; misallocation of available resources has been equally responsible. More specifically, spending choices of the government have been inclined more towards shortterm and publically popular programs like
subsidizing public utilities and commodities. This has compromised the level of public investment in the country.


Role of the financial sector Financial sector plays a crucial role in promoting investment activities in the country, as it mobilizes resources from savers and allocate them to borrowers. In its different phases of development strategies, Pakistan has adopted long-term financing from specialized financial institutions, like PICIC, IDBP, NDFC, etc. However, such institutions lost their importance due to growing inefficiencies. Many of these instititions were unable to extend credit to small borrowers and other desired sectors of the economy such as SME. Government had either privatized them or merged them with other institutions due to their poor management, increasing non performing loans and their burden on the exchequer.( For instance, NDFC was merged with National Bank of Pakistan (NBP) on October 31, 2001 while PICIC was privatized in 2007). Presently, Pakistan’s financial sector is dominated by commercial banks that have gained tremendous strength following the privatization and de-regulation process from 1990s onwards. However, these institutions are not specialized for long-term financing.7 Moreover, government’s reliance on budgetary borrowing from commercial banks has increased lately as: (i) its overall borrowing needs increased significanly due to high budget deficits; (ii) there are statutory limits on borrowing from the cental bank; and (iii) external funding, which only recently showed revival, had almost dried up after FY08.8 On the flip side, commercial banks are also more interested to invest in risk-free government securities instead of locking their funds in long-term private sector proejcts. 9 Thus the role of financial sector has not been supportive for investment in the country. In recent years, policy makers have given attention to development finance; but they are more focused toward financial inclusion – incentive structure for financing long-term projects is still not very accommodative.



Declining foreign investment As domestic resources are insufficient to finance the investment in developing economies, foreign direct investment (FDI) is a viable external resource to fill the gap. FDI not only helps in improving production processes, it also contributes in transferring technology, capacity building of locals and better product development. Pakistan has been attracting foreign companies since independence.10 However, there are many phases of ups and down, due to changing government policies, domestic business conditions, and global economic environment. In early period of 1950s, and 1960s, FDI picked up mainly due to public policies as well expansionary strategies of foreign companies. This trend was discouraged by the nationalization of 1970s. In 1980s and onward, FDI again increased due to favorable policies and incentives for foreign companies
Pakistan was able to attract substantial foreign investment in mid 2000s in banking and telecommunication sectors.12 However, due to deteriorating security situation after 2007, foreign investors avoided Pakistan as an investment destination. Pakistan was unable to perform due to its poor global image, compared to other peer countries, which have enjoyed significant FDI inflows (Figure 5 & 6). Pakistan was not even able to attract foreign investment in lucrative sectors like oil and gas.13 The foreign investment, which did come, was concentrated in services sector, having little spillover impact on manufacturing sectors



Low savings rate While foreign savings are important in financing the saving-investment gap, the most reliable source of funds for investment in a country is its own saving – Pakistan’s record in this aspect is also not encouraging. National savings as percent of GDP were around 10 percent during 1960s, which increased to above 15 percent in 2000s, but declined afterward (Figure 7). Pakistan’s saving rate also compares unfavorably with that in neighboring countries: last five years average saving rate in India was 31.9 percent, Bangladesh 29.7 percent, and Sri Lanka 24.5 percent. Similarly, domestic savings (measured as national savings less net factor income from abroad) also declined from about 15 percent of GDP in 2000s, to less than 9 percent in recent years. Domestic savings are imperative for sustainable growth, because inflow of income from abroad (remittances and other factor income) is uncertain due to cyclical movements in world economies, exchange rates, and external shocks.


Financial savings Low level of saving is one aspect of the problem; other equally important issue is channelizing of saving through financial sector for their efficient allocation to investment. It is found that less than 50 percent of the national savings find its way in to financial sector (Figure 8). The rest is used in real estate or other form of capital formation by informal ways. Interestingly, financial savings (i.e., savings kept in form of financial instruments) declined sharply to 22 percent of the total national savings during 2000-05 – a period of real estate boom.15 Incidentally, the interest rates were also very low during this period.


How to increase investment and saving? With improved security situation and business sentiments in the country, we expect investment to pick up going forward. Encouragingly, the environment of low inflation, low global oil prices, and relatively safer external macro balances has provided a room for government to address structural problems. An important task is to ensure continuity of conducive environment for businesses (e.g., consistent policies, smooth energy availability, improved governance, etc.). Next, the government should design a coherent industrial policy and provide adequate incentives so that manufacturers can move up in the value chain, and invest in technology that will allow shift from producing low value added products to high value products. At the same, the regulatory institutions should be strengthened so that private intellectual rights are suitably enforced and protected. The direct role of the government includes public investment in infrastructure (primarily in electricity and gas distribution, construction, transport and human capital), which crowds in private investment. Given the strong spillover of education on productivity growth, the public investment on R&D and better skill set is critical. A focus on expanding network of technical and vocational education institutions, and establishing industry academia linkages can yield fruitful
results.21 In terms of domestic resource mobilization, the role of the financial sector is critical. Commercial banks in particular should focus on unlocking household savings placed in real estate and precious metals (e.g. gold), and then channelize them into productive investments. Similarly, more schemes are needed to attract contractual saving schemes in private sector like pension, provident fund, gratuity, old age benefit schemes, as well as small savings (like committee/bisi system) into the formal financial system.22 Another area is expanding the network of Islamic banking and offering competitive rate of return on Islamic financial instruments. The role of the government cannot be overemphasized. For example, given government’s heavy reliance on commercial banks for financing its fiscal deficit, banks have little incentive to offer attractive saving schemes and strengthen their capacity to finance long term projects. Thus the government should reduce its overall budget deficit, and also focus on mobilizing funds from non-bank sector.

No comments:

Post a Comment

KIM JOHN UN DIED ?

North Korea’s Kim Jong Un is either dead, brain dead or just fine, depending on which Asian media report you believe. According to ...